Many veterans face the frustrating experience of having their VA disability claims denied due to insufficient medical evidence. According to a 2024 document by the VA Pact Act, the Top 3 reasons for VA Claim denials on decisions on disability claims are: Not Incurred/Caused by Service; No Diagnosis; Not Established by Presumption.  

This means that, without the right documentation, proving the severity or service connection of a disability can be a challenge, resulting in lengthy appeals and, unfortunately, denials.  

Understanding the Importance of Medical Evidence

Medical evidence is the foundation of any VA disability claim. It serves as objective proof of your condition, establishes its connection to your military service, and illustrates how it impacts your daily life. The stronger your medical evidence, the better your chances of a successful appeal. 

Common Types of Medical Evidence include: 

• Service Treatment Records (STRs): Medical records from your time in service documenting injuries or illnesses, such as treatment notes, prescriptions, and lab results. 

• VA Claim Exam (C&P Exam): Assess the current state of your disability and are conducted by VA-approved professionals. 

• Private Medical Records: These come from non-VA providers and include diagnosis, treatment, and ongoing care documentation, such as test results and medical notes. 

• Nexus Letters: A critical document from a qualified healthcare professional linking your disability to your military service. It establishes causation. 

• Lay Statements: Testimonies from family or friends that illustrate how your disability affects your daily life. 

Assessing Your Current Medical Evidence 

Before appealing, it’s essential to evaluate your current medical evidence to ensure it supports your claim. 

Brief Checklist for Evaluation: 

• Review Medical Records 

• Check for Missing or Incomplete Documentation 

• Evaluate Expert Opinions 

Common Pitfalls: 

Relying on Self-Reported Symptoms: While important, self-reported symptoms should be corroborated by medical evidence like diagnostic tests. 

Missing Diagnostic Tests: Lack of tests (e.g., MRIs or X-rays) can make it difficult to prove the severity of your condition. Discuss obtaining necessary tests with your doctor. 

Inconsistent Records: Conflicting medical diagnoses or treatment notes can hurt your credibility. Resolve these inconsistencies by consulting your medical provider for clarification. 

Determining if You Need Additional Evidence 

Additional documentation may be needed if your current evidence needs to be clearer. For instance, consider if you:  

• Lack of Definitive Diagnoses: Further tests or specialist opinions may be necessary if your condition has not been conclusively diagnosed. 

• Have Inconsistent Medical Records: Discrepancies in your records may require additional medical evaluations to resolve. 

• Had No Service Connection Established: If evidence doesn’t firmly tie your disability to your service, you may need a Nexus Letter. 

Types of Additional Evidence for Your VA Appeal: 

• VA-Ordered Medical Examinations: The VA may require further exams to validate your claim conducted by VA-approved medical professionals. 

• Independent Medical Opinions: A second opinion from a private healthcare provider can offer a fresh perspective, especially in cases of VA-provider disagreement. 

• Lay Witness Statements: These statements from people who know you well can complement your evidence by providing insight into the impact of your disability on daily life. 

Seeking Professional Help 

Navigating the VA appeals process can be overwhelming, mainly when gathering and organizing evidence. Consulting a professional can improve your chances of a successful appeal. We have a special guide for those looking to learn about the 4 Common Paths veterans often take to file their VA claims. A well-prepared medical evidence file can make all the difference in obtaining the benefits you deserve. 

Remember, veterans deserve the support they’ve earned. If you want to learn more about medical evidence, contact our team of experts. Start your FREE Medical Evidence evaluation today or watch real testimonials and stories of our clients. 

Related FAQs